A REIT that pays more than it earns
U.S. REITs often report earnings per share of $1 while paying dividends of $1.30. For an ordinary company that would mean paying out more than it earned, but for REITs net income often fails to reflect cash generation, so other measures are used alongside it: FFO and AFFO.
This guide calculates the adjustments from a REIT's net income to FFO and AFFO with a hypothetical REIT. It shows how to compare dividends with each measure and how to check the differing definitions companies use.
REITs and depreciation
Investor.gov describes REITs as companies that own, operate, or finance income-producing real estate. As Nareit explains, REITs that meet certain requirements reduce corporate tax but must pay out most of their taxable income as dividends, which makes dividends a key source of return for investors.
Accounting rules depreciate buildings over their useful lives, creating a large annual expense. Well-maintained property, however, may hold or even gain value over time. The REIT industry has therefore long reported FFO, which adds real estate depreciation back to net income.
A hypothetical REIT
The table walks through the adjustments for a hypothetical REIT with 100 million shares and net income of $100 million. It assumes real estate depreciation of $80 million, a $30 million gain on a property sale, $25 million of recurring maintenance capital spending, and a $10 million straight-line rent adjustment.
| Item | Amount | Per share ($) |
|---|---|---|
| Net income (GAAP) | 100 | 1.00 |
| + Real estate depreciation | +80 | +0.80 |
| − Gain on property sale | −30 | −0.30 |
| FFO | 150 | 1.50 |
| − Recurring maintenance capex | −25 | −0.25 |
| − Straight-line rent adjustment | −10 | −0.10 |
| AFFO | 115 | 1.15 |
| Dividends | 130 | 1.30 |
The $1.30 dividend is 130% of net income, about 87% of FFO, and about 113% of AFFO. The same dividend looks more or less comfortable depending on the measure.
How FFO and AFFO differ
FFO adds real estate depreciation to net income and removes items that do not recur, such as gains or losses from property sales, because a sale gain is a one-time event. An industry definition makes FFO relatively standardized.
AFFO further subtracts the capital spending needed each year to maintain buildings and non-cash accounting adjustments. It comes closer to the cash available for dividends, but there is no standard for which items to subtract, so companies calculate it differently. A dividend above AFFO, as in the table, may mean the REIT pays out more than the cash it generates once maintenance is considered.
Reading dividend capacity
If dividends consistently exceed FFO or AFFO, the gap may be funded by debt, asset sales, or new shares. Investor.gov cautions that non-traded REITs frequently pay distributions in excess of their funds from operations. A year or two of excess may be temporary; several years in a row warrants a closer look at sustainability.
A low payout relative to AFFO means spare cash to reduce debt or buy property. Office, logistics, residential, and data center REITs differ in maintenance needs, so compare AFFO payout ratios within the same property type.
Payout ratios also move with leasing cycles. A REIT renewing many leases in one year may spend heavily on tenant improvements, lowering AFFO temporarily, so a single year's ratio is best read against the lease expiry schedule.
What to check
U.S. REITs include FFO reconciliations in earnings releases and annual reports on SEC EDGAR. Work through these steps.
- Find the reconciliation from net income to FFO and note any items beyond depreciation and sale gains or losses.
- If AFFO is reported, read the company's definition of the maintenance spending and adjustments it subtracts.
- Divide dividends per share by FFO and AFFO per share to calculate payout ratios.
- Check the ratio trend over several years and, when dividends exceed it, what funds the gap in the cash flow statement.
- Review leverage, debt maturities, and lease expiry schedules too.
Limits of non-GAAP measures
FFO and AFFO are not defined by accounting standards; companies report them in addition to GAAP figures. They must be presented with net income and reconciled, but judging what counts as one-time involves discretion. If "one-time" items recur year after year, question whether the adjustments are appropriate.
Because FFO adds back all depreciation, it can overstate profitability for REITs whose properties genuinely age and lose value. In those cases, AFFO and the scale of maintenance spending matter more.
Variables beyond the numbers
The amounts here are hypothetical and illustrate the adjustments. Real REITs define FFO and AFFO differently, and Korean REITs differ from U.S. REITs in disclosure and tax.
When looking at a real REIT, check its latest earnings release and filings with their revision dates in mind. This guide does not recommend buying or selling anything.