01

Cash received, but not yet revenue?

A software company that collects a year's subscription fee up front does not record it all as January revenue. It recognizes revenue over the twelve months of service and holds the unearned portion as deferred revenue, a contract liability.

This post looks at what deferred revenue is, how contract liabilities differ from cash, and when revenue is recognized, using a hypothetical subscription business. It also covers reading the differences between billings, revenue, and cash, and the renewal and refund indicators worth checking.

02

What deferred revenue means

IFRS 15, and ASC 606 under U.S. GAAP, require consideration received before goods or services are transferred to be recognized as a contract liability. Deferred revenue is the most common example. It is labeled a liability, but most of it will become revenue as service is delivered.

A steadily growing deferred revenue balance suggests future revenue is building up. A balance that starts to shrink can signal weakening new sales or renewals.

03

A hypothetical subscription company

The table follows a hypothetical company that collects a $1.2 billion annual subscription fee on January 1 and recognizes revenue quarterly. For clarity, it assumes no other contracts.

Prepaid subscription turning into revenue (hypothetical, $ millions)
QuarterCash receivedRevenue recognizedDeferred revenue at quarter-end
Q11,200300900
Q20300600
Q30300300
Q403000
Full year1,2001,200-

In Q1, cash exceeds revenue by $900 million; afterward, revenue is recognized with no new cash. That is why Q1 operating cash flow can look unusually strong.

04

Contract liabilities and cash

Because cash arrives before revenue, a growing prepaid business typically shows operating cash flow above net income: the increase in deferred revenue is added in the operating section. That is how some subscription companies can be unprofitable yet comfortable on cash.

When growth stops and deferred revenue shrinks, the effect reverses. Revenue is recognized from cash collected earlier while less new cash arrives, and operating cash flow can fall below net income. Check whether strong cash flow is driven by rising deferred revenue.

In a hypothetical case, a company with $100 million of net income whose deferred revenue rises by $80 million might report operating cash flow near $180 million. If the next year deferred revenue falls by $40 million with the same profit, operating cash flow could drop to about $60 million without any change in the underlying business.

05

Reading growth through billings

Many subscription companies report billings, roughly revenue plus the change in deferred revenue, which shows how much was newly invoiced in the period. Revenue reflects past contracts with a lag; billings reflect recent sales sooner.

Here is a hypothetical example: revenue of $1.3 billion with deferred revenue up $200 million implies billings of about $1.5 billion. Billings growth slowing below revenue growth can foreshadow slower revenue ahead. A change in billing terms, such as moving from annual to monthly invoicing, can move billings sharply on its own, so read the explanation.

06

Renewal and refund indicators

Deferred revenue becomes revenue only if service continues. If customers can cancel and receive refunds, part of the balance may have to be returned rather than recognized. Check refund terms and any refund liability the company discloses.

Renewal rates matter too. The share of customers who renew, and whether existing customers spend more or less, are often reported as separate metrics in earnings materials. Falling renewals slow the build-up of deferred revenue.

Investor.gov's guide to the 10-K and 10-Q points to the MD&A, where subscription companies usually discuss these metrics and how they define them, which is important because definitions differ between companies.

07

Notes and definitions to check

Using the 10-K and 10-Q on EDGAR, work through these steps.

  1. Find the contract liability balance and the amount of the opening balance recognized as revenue in the period.
  2. Check remaining performance obligations and the expected timing of recognition.
  3. Estimate billings from revenue and the change in deferred revenue, and compare with revenue growth.
  4. See how much the change in contract liabilities contributed to operating cash flow.
  5. Review refund terms, refund liabilities, and the company's renewal or retention metrics.
08

Limits of deferred revenue analysis

Deferred revenue depends heavily on contract structure and billing frequency, so its meaning varies even within an industry. A company that bills multi-year contracts up front and one that bills monthly cannot be compared directly.

The company in the table is hypothetical. When analyzing a real business, use the latest filings with their dates and read deferred revenue and billings alongside revenue, cash flow, and renewal metrics.