Money a company has promised its employees
A company with a defined benefit pension plan promises employees a set amount in retirement based on their years of service and pay. Those payments may be decades away, but the promise is a liability today. The assets the company sets aside to meet it are the plan assets.
Here we cover how the pension obligation and plan assets are measured, what the gap between them means for a company's finances, and why the funded status can move sharply with small changes in the discount rate, using a hypothetical calculation. It also lists the assumptions to check in the notes.
How defined benefit plans work
Pension plans broadly come in two types. In a defined contribution plan, the company pays a set amount each year and the employee bears the investment result. In a defined benefit plan, the company promises the payout, so if plan assets underperform or employees live longer than expected, the company must make up the difference.
IAS 19 requires the defined benefit obligation to be measured by projecting future benefits using actuarial assumptions and discounting them to present value; U.S. GAAP takes a similar approach. The liability is therefore an estimate that depends heavily on assumptions about salary growth, turnover, life expectancy, and the discount rate.
Obligation and plan assets
The balance sheet shows the net defined benefit liability (or asset): the obligation minus the fair value of plan assets. When assets fall short, the gap is a liability; when they exceed the obligation, a surplus may be recognized within limits.
The funded ratio, plan assets divided by the obligation, shows how much of the promise has been set aside in advance. A poorly funded plan is likely to need extra contributions, and that cash comes from money that could otherwise fund dividends or investment.
A hypothetical funded-status calculation
The table shows a hypothetical company with a $1 billion obligation and $850 million of plan assets, and how the funded status changes if the discount rate moves by one percentage point. The obligation's duration is assumed to be 12 years, simplified to mean a 12% change in the obligation per point.
| Discount rate | Obligation | Plan assets | Funding gap | Funded ratio |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3% (−1 pt) | ≈ 1,120 | 850 | ≈ −270 | ≈ 75.9% |
| 4% (current) | 1,000 | 850 | −150 | 85.0% |
| 5% (+1 pt) | ≈ 880 | 850 | ≈ −30 | ≈ 96.6% |
With plan assets unchanged, a one-point move in the discount rate swings the gap between $30 million and $270 million. In practice, bond-heavy plan assets also move when rates change.
Discount-rate sensitivity
The discount rate is usually based on yields of high-quality corporate bonds. When interest rates fall, the discount rate falls, the present value of future payments rises, and the obligation grows. That is why many companies' pension deficits widened during periods of falling rates.
Plans that hold bonds matching the obligation's duration see asset values rise along with the obligation when rates fall, which steadies the funding gap. Plans weighted toward equities can see deficits jump if falling rates coincide with falling stock prices, so the asset mix matters.
Some companies deliberately shift plan assets toward bonds as funding improves, a strategy sometimes called liability-driven investing. The notes usually describe the target allocation, which shows how much of the funded status is exposed to markets.
Assumptions to check in the notes
The pension note in the 10-K on EDGAR contains the key details.
- Find the opening and closing defined benefit obligation, fair value of plan assets, and net liability or asset.
- Check the discount rate, salary-growth assumption, and the sensitivity of the obligation to a one-point change in each.
- Review the composition of plan assets: cash, bonds, equities, insurance contracts, and so on.
- Note the obligation's weighted-average duration and expected future benefit payments.
- Compare expected employer contributions for next year with actual contributions in recent years.
What the numbers mean
A funding gap is a balance-sheet liability and a signal that the company may have to put in cash. If the gap is large relative to operating income or market value, less cash may be left for shareholders. Including pension deficits in net debt gives a more conservative view of the true debt burden.
Gains and losses from changes in actuarial assumptions are usually recorded in other comprehensive income rather than net income. Looking only at net income can miss changes in the pension burden, so check comprehensive income and equity movements as well.
Limits of comparison
Because the obligation rests on many assumptions, companies in the same industry can report figures that are hard to compare. A higher discount rate makes the obligation look smaller, so check assumptions when comparing.
The funded-status calculation is a simplified hypothetical. When analyzing a real company, use the notes in the latest filings, noting when each was last updated and look at both the size of any gap and its sensitivity to interest rates.