Is it really a non-cash cost?
Technology companies' earnings releases often feature adjusted earnings excluding stock-based compensation. Paying employees in shares uses no company cash, the argument goes, so excluding the expense shows profitability better. But someone bears the cost of equity pay: existing shareholders.
This guide calculates, with a hypothetical company, how stock-based compensation is recorded and how it reaches shareholders through dilution, buybacks, and tax withholding payments. It shows how to restore the cost when reading adjusted earnings and cash flow, and what to check in the filings.
How it is recorded
IFRS 2 requires companies that receive employee services in exchange for shares or share-linked rights to recognize the expense over the vesting period, based on fair value at the grant date. Shares vesting over four years produce expense spread over four years, because, like cash pay, they are payment for services.
Because no cash leaves, the expense is added back when calculating operating cash flow. Companies with heavy equity pay therefore often report operating cash flow far above net income, which creates the impression of a cost that uses no cash.
A hypothetical company
The table assumes a company with 100 million shares that records stock-based compensation of 120 in a year, delivers 3 million shares to employees, and buys back 2 million shares for 100 to limit dilution. When delivering shares, it withholds some and pays 30 in cash to cover employees' taxes.
| Item | Amount | Reading |
|---|---|---|
| Reported net income (after 120 of stock compensation) | 500 | Profit under accounting rules |
| "Adjusted" net income excluding stock compensation | 620 | Profit without the pay cost |
| Operating cash flow (120 non-cash expense added back) | 800 | The non-cash cost is added back |
| Buybacks to offset dilution | −100 | Cash actually spent |
| Tax withholding paid on net settlement | −30 | Cash actually spent |
| Change in shares (3 million delivered − 2 million bought) | +1 million | 1% dilution remains |
The pay was not settled in cash, yet the company spent 130 in cash limiting dilution, and the share count still rose 1%.
How shareholders bear it
If the company does nothing, newly delivered shares increase the share count and dilute existing holders. If it buys back shares to prevent dilution, cash leaves the company. Either way, equity compensation is paid out of shareholders' share. The company in the table experienced both.
Diluted earnings per share under IAS 33 tries to show this burden by including awards not yet delivered in the share count. A large gap between basic and diluted EPS signals that the share count may grow further.
Recalculating adjusted measures
Using adjusted earnings that exclude stock compensation makes a company look more profitable than a peer that pays the same people in cash. For a fair comparison, subtract the expense again or at least note stock compensation as a share of revenue alongside it.
The same applies to free cash flow. Even if the company in the table reports strong free cash flow, buybacks to offset dilution and withholding payments that recur every year should be subtracted to approach the cash actually left for shareholders.
A simple ratio helps over time: stock compensation divided by revenue. A ratio that stays flat or falls as the company grows suggests the cost is under control; one that keeps rising means a growing share of the business is being paid to employees in equity.
Items to verify
Notes on stock compensation are in annual reports on SEC EDGAR for U.S. companies and in business reports on DART for Korean companies.
- Find the year's stock-based compensation expense and its ratio to revenue in the income statement and notes.
- Check the unrecognized cost of unvested awards and the period over which it will be expensed.
- Compare the annual change in shares outstanding and diluted EPS with basic EPS.
- Find buybacks made to offset dilution and cash paid for tax withholding in the cash flow statement.
- Check how stock compensation is treated in the reconciliations for adjusted earnings and adjusted cash flow.
Share price and compensation cost
Because the expense is fixed at grant-date fair value, a later rise in the share price does not change the accounting cost. A higher price, though, makes the buybacks needed to offset the same number of delivered shares more expensive. The accounting cost and the economic burden can move apart.
If the share price falls sharply, more shares may be needed to deliver the same value of pay, increasing dilution. The burden of equity pay is clearer when share counts and cash flows are read together rather than from the expense figure alone.
Scope of the example
The amounts and share counts here are hypothetical. Real compensation structures, accounting, and taxes vary by company and country.
When looking at a real company, check IFRS 2 and the notes to its latest annual report along with the date of each. This guide does not recommend buying or selling anything.